Hi there,
Most brands give subscribers one option when they want to leave.
Unsubscribe completely.
But here's the thing.
Most people don't want to leave forever.
They just want fewer emails. Or more relevant ones.
And if you only give them one option, you lose them completely when you didn't have to.
The Fix: A Manage Preferences Page
Instead of a single unsubscribe button, you give them two choices.
Choice 1: Adjust Frequency
Let them tell you how often they want to hear from you.
Every email
Once a week
Once a month
Some people love hearing from you. They just don't want their inbox flooded. Give them the option to dial it back instead of leaving.
Choice 2: Choose Content Type
Let them tell you what they actually want to receive.
All emails
Sales and promotions only
New product launches only
Newsletter only
Someone who only wants sale alerts doesn't need your weekly newsletter. Let them filter it. They stay on your list. They buy when it matters.
Why This Matters:
Every subscriber you keep is one less person you have to re-acquire through ads.
Unsubscribes cost you money twice. Once when they leave. Again when you pay to replace them.
A manage preferences page costs you nothing to build and keeps subscribers you would have lost completely.
How to Implement:
Build a manage preferences page as a hosted page inside Klaviyo (Audience -> Lists & Segments -> click your main email list -> Preferences -> Consent Page)
Add two sections: frequency preference and content type preference
Map each selection to the right segment or tag in Klaviyo
Replace your default unsubscribe link with a link to this page
Give people a reason to stay.
Most will take it.
Hope this helps.
Best,
Luca
Free Resources
Resources to help you scale
Use these resources to help improve your brand’s email marketing.
100-Page Email Marketing Guide (2026)
The complete playbook for email marketing across flows, campaigns, list growth, and deliverability.
Get the GuidePlug-and-Play Figma Email Designs
Reusable email and pop-up design templates built from real client work to speed up production.
Get the Figma FileEmail Marketing AI Assistant (Custom GPT)
A custom GPT trained on Grow Pronto's frameworks and content. Use it to generate campaign ideas, write email copy, or get answers to any email marketing question.
Get the Guide
