Hi there,

Hiring the wrong email agency is an expensive mistake.

You lose time, money, and momentum. And you're back to square one 6 months later looking for someone else.

Here are 9 things to look for before you sign a contract. These are in no particular order.

1. Caliber of brands they've worked with.

Big brands are selective about who they trust with their email marketing. If an agency has worked with recognizable names in your space, that's a strong signal they know what they're doing.

2. Case studies.

An obvious one, but worth saying. If an agency can't show you real results from real brands, move on.

3. Direct experience in your industry.

There's a big difference between an agency that has worked in your space and one that hasn't. If they've managed email for a direct competitor or a brand in your category, they can speak to your specific situation with far deeper expertise. That alone can make them the obvious choice.

4. Price.

If an agency is charging you $2,000 a month, ask yourself how they're affording an expert email marketing manager, a designer, and a copywriter all working on your account. The answer is they're not. Low price usually means low quality talent working on your brand.

5. Campaign volume.

It doesn't make much sense to pay an agency $5,000 a month to send only 2-4 email campaigns. I've seen this more times than I would have thought possible. Ask upfront how many campaigns they send per month and what's included.

6. Where is the team based?

A lot of agencies will take your money and hand your account off to an offshore team that doesn't fully understand your brand or culture. If brand voice matters to you, and it should, make sure you know exactly who is writing your emails.

7. How many active clients do they have?

You don't want an agency with 5 clients that is just starting out. But you also don't want one with 200 clients operating on a churn and burn model where your account gets minimal attention. Find the sweet spot.

8. Is the founder involved?

The majority of an agency's knowledge comes from the founder. The closer you can get to that knowledge, the better. If the founder is completely removed from day to day work, you're getting a watered down version of their strategy executed by a junior account manager who didn't build it.

9. How sophisticated is their strategy?

Is the agency only sending campaigns? Or are they providing deeper retention insights across the full scope of email, SMS, and loyalty? An agency that only sends campaigns for $2,000 a month is not a retention partner. There's a big difference.

After going through this process hundreds of times, these are the 9 things I'd check before making a decision.

If you want to see how Grow Pronto stacks up against this list, you can learn more at growpronto.com.

Hope this helps.

Best,
Luca

Free Resources

Resources to help you scale

Use these resources to help improve your brand’s pop-ups.

  1. 100-Page Email Marketing Guide (2026)
    The complete playbook for email marketing across flows, campaigns, list growth, and deliverability.
    Get the Guide

  2. Email Flows Guide
    A complete breakdown of all 8 core email flows and how to set them up for maximum revenue.
    Get the Guide

  3. Email Marketing AI Assistant (Custom GPT)
    A custom GPT trained on Grow Pronto's frameworks and content. Use it to generate campaign ideas, write email copy, or get answers to any email marketing question.
    Get the Custom GPT